Book Review: Call Sign Chaos

  |   Books Print Friendly and PDF

Here’s the short version of this review. I expected great things from Call Sign Chaos: Learning to Lead and it exceeded my expectations. Details follow.

Unless you’ve been living under a rock for the last decade or so, you know who Jim Mattis is. He’s the Marine general with the nicknames “Mad Dog” and “The Warrior Monk.” He’s known for his blunt statements and his extensive reading. You may not know who Bing West is. He’s a Marine combat veteran who has written several books. I’ve read two, The March Up and The Village. They were both excellent. The two men make a great team.

Call Sign Chaos isn’t a leadership textbook or a treatise on leadership development. It’s the story of Jim Mattis developing from a “carefree” young man to a seasoned and savvy leader. Here’s his statement of the book’s purpose.

“My purpose in writing this book is to convey the lessons I learned for those who might benefit, whether in the military or in civilian life.”

The book is divided into three parts. The first is called “Direct Leadership.” Next is “Executive Leadership.” And, finally, there is “Strategic Leadership.”

Direct Leadership is about leading face-to-face. It’s the kind of leadership where you know all the people you’re leading. In business direct leadership is first-line supervision and most of middle-management.

The second section is Executive Leadership. That’s leadership when it’s no longer possible to know every person under your leadership umbrella. For me, that occurred when I was promoted from being the manager of a regional service center to the manager of all my company’s service centers.

If you want to be an effective executive leader, you must change the way you lead. If I’d had a book like this, I would have known that I needed to make a transition and learned what I needed to do differently. You can’t know every individual person under your umbrella. You must learn to lead them all through the limited number of leaders you encounter on a regular basis. You must also develop independent sources of information and stay in touch with the men and women on the front line. Business leaders make this transition when they move into general management.

The third section is about strategic leadership. Mattis describes his challenges as a military leader with civilian bosses. He describes how political concerns are as important as operational ones. There’s no real analogy to this for most business leaders. It’s interesting to read. There are insights scattered throughout. But this will probably not be part of your learning environment until/unless you reach the top of a large corporation.

Be prepared to make lots of notes. Make sure you’re well-stocked with highlighters and sticky notes. There is a lot of wisdom scattered through the book, as well as pointers to other resources.

Movie directors talk about “through-lines.” This book has lots of “through-lessons.” Here are three that stood out to me.

Reading really is fundamental. Leaders really are readers. They don’t call him the Warrior Monk for nothing. There are two things in the book about leadership and reading that will make a difference for you. First, there is the example. You will witness Mattis pulling books out of his rucksack to study, check a fact, or make a point.  You’ll also get pointers to lots of individual reading resources that are relevant for you, even if you aren’t a military leader.

One of the things I learned in the Marine Corps was the purpose and practice of the after-action review. That’s another lesson that runs through the book. Jim Mattis describes his personal after-action reviews for situations that didn’t work out as he’d hoped. Instead of blaming others, he focuses on his actions and what he could have done differently. The lesson is excellent, and it’s repeated several times.

It’s all about the front line. My friend, Mel Kleiman, likes to say, “Without the front line, there is no bottom line.” Mattis expresses the same thought in different words. He says that if you can’t talk to the people at the very front line, you’re out of touch. He stresses the importance of concentrating on doing things that will help those front-line folks. Here’s how he puts it on one occasion.

“Much of what I carried with me was summed up in a handwritten card that lay on my Pentagon desk these past few years, the desk where I signed deployment orders, sending troops overseas. It read, ‘Will this commitment contribute sufficiently to the wellbeing of the American people to justify putting our troops in a position to die?’”

In A Nutshell

Call Sign Chaos: Learning to Lead is an excellent book about one man’s leadership development. Whether you’re in the military or in business, there are lots of lessons for you. You’ll learn that direct leadership is different than executive leadership, what to do in each case, and how to adapt from one to the other. You’ll come away with dozens of notes, pithy quotes about leadership and life, and pointers to a boatload of resources. If you are serious about leadership, you must read this book.

You can check out some of my highlights and notes from this book on my GoodReads page.

-o0o-

What’s the fastest way to learn the big ideas from a great business book? Book summaries. Check out summaries from The Business Source, where you can watch, read, or listen to the big ideas from a great book in under 20 minutes.

Join The Conversation

Cancel

What People Are Saying

Michael Wade   |   11 Nov 2019   |   Reply

Wally,

I have taken time off from reading General Mattis’s book to read one of his recommendations: “Scipio Africanus” by B. H. Liddell Hart.

One thing that bugged me about the Mattis book: the email copied on pages 258-259. Unfortunately, the email was probably written in haste and it has mistakes. Rudyard Kipling, not Rudyard Lawrence, wrote “Kim.” William, not Willaam, Manchester wrote “American Caesar” and “Goodbye Darkness.” Barbara Tuchman, not Tuckman, wrote “The March of Folly” and “The Guns of August.” There were some other errors as well.

That aside, Mattis is too good to miss. I will be finishing his book soon. After all, he was right about “Scipio Africanus.”

Best regards,

Michael

Wally Bock   |   12 Nov 2019   |   Reply

That email reprint didn’t bother me. When I work with a client on a book, that would be a client decision. Some want the original, with all the errors. Others want to clean it up. On another note, Liddell Hart is one of my favorite writers on military history of all kinds, especially portraits of leaders. I love The Great Captains Unveiled. Amazon requires that I tell you the link is an affiliate link and I will receive a small commission if you follow the link and buy the book.